Feedback Friday
A thread opens on Discord. Feedback Friday works when everyone plays one: post your game, play someone else's, and leave notes in their thread.
Where to post, how feedback works, and the few rules we keep. Read it in five minutes, then come and show us what you're building.
You don't need a finished game, or any game at all yet. These four steps are the quickest way to get useful feedback.
That's where most of the guild talks. If you'd rather post publicly, r/KilnGuild works too.
Post in #introductions: what you're building, which AI tools you use, and what you're stuck on. Here to play? Say what kinds of games you like.
Leave them one useful note before you ask for any. People notice who gives, and they give back.
Drop it in #feedback-wanted using the template below. Rough is fine. Unplayable is fine if you say so.
A few regular events keep things moving, so there's always a good moment to post.
A thread opens on Discord. Feedback Friday works when everyone plays one: post your game, play someone else's, and leave notes in their thread.
Finished it? Post it in #show-your-game with your itch.io or Steam link. This is the place for self-promotion, so it's welcome here.
Our first jam on itch.io. Any AI tools allowed, as long as you list them. Get email updates to hear when it opens.
Good feedback is specific. These two halves are how we keep it that way.
The more you tell people, the better notes you'll get.
Game: (name + one line on what it is) Play it: (link, browser-playable if you can) Time to play: (e.g. 5 min) Made with: (AI tools you used, e.g. Claude for code, Midjourney for art) I want feedback on: (1–2 specific things, e.g. "is the first level too hard?") Known issues: (so nobody reports them twice)
Play first, then write. Two minutes of honest notes beats ten "looks cool!" comments.
Played 8 min, reached level 3. The dash feels great, really snappy. Got stuck on the moving platforms: I didn't realise you could wall-jump. Maybe show it once in level 1?
These are the same on Discord and Reddit. Moderators remove posts that break them.
Criticise the game, not the person. Harsh is OK; cruel isn't.
It's the most useful thing you can share, and nobody here will judge you for it.
No characters, art or music you don't own, whether AI-generated or not. Copying someone else's IP gets removed.
Store links and launch posts belong in #show-your-game. Asking for feedback? Then use #feedback-wanted.
One post per game per week. Updates go in your existing thread.
No sexual content or explicit nudity. Violence, horror and dark stories are fine, as long as you add a content warning. Sexualised characters who look underage, or sexual or degrading images of real people, mean an instant ban.
Share downloadable games through itch.io, Steam, Google Play, the App Store or a similar store page. No zip or exe files, and no file-hosting links (MediaFire, Google Drive, Mega...). Browser games and videos are fine as always. Links that look unsafe are removed straight away.
The Discord channels, in the order most people use them.
#introductionsSay hi: what you're building and with which tools, or what kinds of games you like to play.
#feedback-wantedPlayable builds and feedback requests (use the template).
#show-your-gameScreenshots, clips, progress you're proud of, and finished games with store links.
#tools-and-promptsWhat worked, what didn't, prompts worth stealing.
#generalEverything else about making games with AI.
No. Many members build entirely by prompting AI. If you can describe what you want and test the result, you're in the right place.
No. On kilnguild.com you can play the games, leave a comment under any of them, log in with Google and add your own game, all without Discord. Feedback Friday and the note threads happen on the Discord, which is free to join.
Yes. Joining the Discord and subreddit, posting and getting feedback cost nothing.
No. Any amount of AI counts, from code and art to music, writing or just debugging help. Just say what you used.
No sexual content or explicit nudity, anywhere in KilnGuild. Mature themes like violence, horror or a dark story are welcome: just put a content warning at the top of your post, e.g. "CW: gore, death".
No. Feedback is most useful early, before you've spent weeks on the wrong idea. Tell people it's rough and what you want to know.
Makers can add a link to their own store or tip page. KilnGuild doesn't sell games or take a cut.
That's the plan, built around what the community actually uses. Leave your email to hear when it opens.
An idea, a broken prototype, a nearly finished game: all welcome.